Movie Reviews - Featured Films » Independent Film Guide - J

Jane Eyre Movie Review

zeffirelli franco joan charlotte

When we want to see Jane Eyre, we can buy the 1934 version from Sinister Cinema or we can rent the 1944 all-star classic from Fox Video or we can watch the 1970 telefeature that turns up every so often on double-digit UHF channels or we can plow through all six hours of the 1983 PBS miniseries. Clearly, there is no shortage of Jane Eyres and Edward Rochesters in this century. Does this 1847 saga by Charlotte Brontë have anything new to say to the audiences of 1996? Director Franco Zeffirelli clearly thinks so, and his latest movie is a fairly faithful adaptation marred by serious miscasting. William Hurt may look like the subject of an early daguerreotype, but the instant he opens his mouth, we get to hear a Mr. Rochester who owes more to Elmer Fudd than Orson Welles. His interpretation throws the film off balance; aside from a self-conscious scowl, he seems entirely disinterested in Jane or Thornfield or anything. Charlotte Gainsbourg's Jane speaks with a constant lisp, which may not be as detectable in her many French film assignments, but it clearly eliminates the possibility of Jane's extended narrations. (The charismatic Amanda Root has a small role as Miss Temple; why couldn't SHE have played Jane opposite someone like Gabriel Byrne?) Elle Macpherson's Blanche Ingram is reduced to a walk-on bit, ditto Maria Schneider as Rochester's mad first wife. Joan Plowright is wonderful as Mrs. Hudson and Billie Whitelaw has a few splendid, but all-too-brief sequences as Grace Poole. This Jane Eyre sounds like it will be better than it looks until you're watching it and then it looks better than it sounds. Do we care a fig for THESE repressed lovers? Not this time; bring back Orson Welles and Joan Fontaine and Hillary Brooke!

1996 (PG) 116m/C William Hurt, Anna Paquin, Charlotte Gainsbourg, Joan Plowright, Elle Macpherson, Geraldine Chaplin, Fiona Shaw, John Wood, Amanda Root, Maria Schneider, Josephine Serre, Billie Whitelaw; D: Franco Zeffirelli; W: Franco Zeffirelli, Hugh Whitemore; C: David Watkin; M: Alessio Vlad, Claudio Capponi. VHS, LV, Closed Caption

John and Julie Movie Review [next] [back] Jacques Brel Is Alive and Well and Living in Paris Movie Review

User Comments

Your email address will be altered so spam harvesting bots can't read it easily.
Hide my email completely instead?

Cancel or